China Market Commentary: February 2023
Here are this month’s highlights: In just two years, the MSCI India Index’s weighting to Adani companies increased from 1.2% to 5.8% in aggregate, despite many people’s concerns of poor governance. A key question that arises as a consequence of this saga is whether the “E” (within ESG) was so compelling that the “G” could be compromised. By Western standards, one of the main reasons for the poor governance in emerging markets is due to the presence of a controlling shareholder – usually the founder and their family, or the state. Private enterprises run the risk of being managed for the benefit of the majority shareholder and not stakeholders in general, which in its extreme could lead to fraud. In the private sector, we all know how much value a visionary leader, usually the founder and controlling shareholder of the business, can create over time by focusing on the strategic plans rather than quarter-over-quarter financial results – think of the founders of the great internet companies. While it is not always black or white, we argue that fund managers should always be careful when taking on poor governance as the results could be binary – all or nothing.